Pain lands

15 Commander-legal cards are pain lands. The most-played are Shivan Reef, Battlefield Forge and Caves of Koilos (card data dated November 18, 2026).

Pain lands tap for colourless mana for free, or for either of two colours at 1 damage to you. The 15 Commander-legal pain lands.

Build a deck around these cards: describe it to Grover, the AI deck assistant, and it drafts a full Commander list with the reasoning behind every pick.

Best pain lands in Commander

Ranked most-played first, the best pain lands in Commander are Shivan Reef, Battlefield Forge, Caves of Koilos, Yavimaya Coast and Llanowar Wastes. Every card on this list is legal in Commander as of the card data dated November 18, 2026.

What these cards do

Pain lands are what players call the lands that tap for colourless mana at no cost, or for either of two colours at 1 damage to you; the name is not printed on the cards. Ten enter untapped, one for each colour pair, among them Shivan Reef, Caves of Koilos and Battlefield Forge, and five from Tempest enter tapped.

Two- and three-colour decks play them as untapped duals that are cheap to own, and at 40 starting life a few points of damage rarely decide a game. Where the damage adds up, the check lands and the fast lands make both colours without it, under a condition.

Rules note: the 1 damage is part of the mana ability, so it happens as you tap the land and can't be responded to; tapping for colourless deals none.

The list

15 cards in all, most-played first. Every card links to its page with printings, prices and format legality.

  1. Shivan Reef (Land)
  2. Battlefield Forge (Land)
  3. Caves of Koilos (Land)
  4. Yavimaya Coast (Land)
  5. Llanowar Wastes (Land)
  6. Underground River (Land)
  7. Adarkar Wastes (Land)
  8. Sulfurous Springs (Land)
  9. Karplusan Forest (Land)
  10. Brushland (Land)
  11. Caldera Lake (Land)
  12. Salt Flats (Land)
  13. Pine Barrens (Land)
  14. Scabland (Land)
  15. Skyshroud Forest (Land)

How this list is built

Commander-legal lands that tap for colourless mana, and for either of two colours with 1 damage to you. City of Brass, which deals damage whenever it becomes tapped, and lands that make one colour with damage are not listed. One entry per card, most-played first.

Built from the card data dated 2026-11-18.

Frequently asked questions

What are pain lands in MTG?

Lands that tap for colourless mana for free, or for one of two colours with 1 damage to you. The name is a player nickname; ten enter untapped and five from Tempest enter tapped.

Can I respond to a pain land's damage?

No. Tapping a land for mana is a mana ability, which doesn't go on the stack and resolves at once (rule 605.3b), so the damage comes with the mana.

How much do pain lands hurt in Commander?

1 damage for each coloured mana they make, none for colourless. Each player starts a Commander game at 40 life (rule 903.7), so most decks can afford a few.

Sources

  • Comprehensive Rules, effective November 6, 2026: rules 605.3b (mana abilities) and 903.7 (starting life in Commander).
  • Mana Grove card database, MTGJSON build of November 18, 2026: the rules text, type line and Commander legality of every card on this list, and the deck-inclusion popularity rank behind its order.

How our guides are made.

Guides

Explore Mana Grove