Black tutors

100 Commander-legal cards are black tutors. The most-played are Demonic Tutor, Vampiric Tutor and Diabolic Intent (card data dated November 18, 2026).

Black tutors search your library for a card, and each fits any Commander deck with black in its colours. The 100 black tutors, most-played first.

Build a deck around these cards: describe it to Grover, the AI deck assistant, and it drafts a full Commander list with the reasoning behind every pick.

Best black tutors in Commander

Ranked most-played first, the best black tutors in Commander are Demonic Tutor, Vampiric Tutor, Diabolic Intent, Entomb and Buried Alive. Every card on this list is legal in Commander as of the card data dated November 18, 2026.

What these cards do

Black tutors are the cards of black alone that search your library for another card, so each one fits any Commander deck whose colour identity includes black. Black finds any card, paid for in life, cards or tempo, with Demonic Tutor, Vampiric Tutor, Imperial Seal and Diabolic Intent. Most put the card into your hand; others put it on top of your library, onto the battlefield or into your graveyard.

This is the MTG tutors list filtered by Commander colour identity: a card's identity counts every colour in its mana cost and rules text, so a gold or hybrid tutor that also needs another colour sits on neither one-colour list, and colourless tutors, which fit every deck, are on the full tutors list.

Rules note: colour identity also counts mana symbols in the rules text, so a black card with an ability that costs another colour is not on this list; and a tutor that names a quality, such as a creature card, may come up empty.

The list

100 cards in all, most-played first. Every card links to its page with printings, prices and format legality.

  1. Demonic Tutor (Sorcery)
  2. Vampiric Tutor (Instant)
  3. Diabolic Intent (Sorcery)
  4. Entomb (Instant)
  5. Buried Alive (Sorcery)
  6. Diabolic Tutor (Sorcery)
  7. Wishclaw Talisman (Artifact)
  8. Imperial Seal (Sorcery)
  9. Grim Tutor (Sorcery)
  10. Beseech the Mirror (Sorcery)
  11. Insatiable Avarice (Sorcery)
  12. Rune-Scarred Demon (Creature - Demon)
  13. Unmarked Grave (Sorcery)
  14. Profane Tutor (Sorcery)
  15. Lively Dirge (Sorcery)
  16. Hoarding Broodlord (Creature - Dragon)
  17. Demonic Counsel (Sorcery)
  18. Scheming Symmetry (Sorcery)
  19. Razaketh, the Foulblooded (Legendary Creature - Demon)
  20. Vile Entomber (Creature - Zombie Warlock)
  21. Varragoth, Bloodsky Sire (Legendary Creature - Demon Rogue)
  22. Final Parting (Sorcery)
  23. Sidisi, Undead Vizier (Legendary Creature - Zombie Snake)
  24. Beseech the Queen (Sorcery)
  25. Gravebreaker Lamia (Enchantment Creature - Snake Lamia)
  26. Emeritus of Woe // Demonic Tutor (Creature - Vampire Warlock)
  27. Dark Petition (Sorcery)
  28. Grim Servant (Creature - Zombie Warlock)
  29. The Cruelty of Gix (Enchantment - Saga)
  30. Burning-Rune Demon (Creature - Demon Berserker)
  31. Liliana Vess (Legendary Planeswalker - Liliana)
  32. Oriq Loremage (Creature - Human Warlock)
  33. Doomsday (Sorcery)
  34. Dimir House Guard (Creature - Skeleton)
  35. Splinter's Technique (Sorcery)
  36. Cruel Tutor (Sorcery)
  37. Case of the Stashed Skeleton (Enchantment - Case)
  38. Coveted Prize (Sorcery)
  39. Ayara's Oathsworn (Creature - Human Knight)
  40. Mausoleum Secrets (Instant)
  41. Forerunner of the Coalition (Creature - Human Pirate)
  42. Ratcatcher (Creature - Ogre Rogue)
  43. Shred Memory (Instant)
  44. The Creation of Avacyn (Enchantment - Saga)
  45. Mastermind's Acquisition (Sorcery)
  46. Diabolic Revelation (Sorcery)
  47. Cynical Loner (Creature - Human Survivor)
  48. Corpse Connoisseur (Creature - Zombie Wizard)
  49. Curse of Misfortunes (Enchantment - Aura Curse)
  50. Increasing Ambition (Sorcery)
  51. Secret Salvage (Sorcery)
  52. Razaketh's Rite (Sorcery)
  53. Maralen of the Mornsong (Legendary Creature - Elf Wizard)
  54. Servant of the Stinger (Creature - Human Warlock)
  55. Shadowborn Apostle (Creature - Human Cleric)
  56. Illicit Shipment (Sorcery)
  57. Boggart Harbinger (Creature - Goblin Shaman)
  58. Shadow-Rite Priest (Creature - Human Cleric)
  59. Mornsong Aria (Legendary Enchantment)
  60. Dimir Machinations (Sorcery)
  61. Insidious Dreams (Instant)
  62. Corpse Harvester (Creature - Zombie Wizard)
  63. Bitterheart Witch (Creature - Human Shaman)
  64. Behold the Beyond (Sorcery)
  65. Blood Speaker (Creature - Ogre Shaman)
  66. Rhystic Tutor (Sorcery)
  67. Hour of Victory (Enchantment)
  68. Brainspoil (Sorcery)
  69. Liliana's Influence (Sorcery)
  70. Demonic Bargain (Sorcery)
  71. Demonic Collusion (Sorcery)
  72. Lo and Li, Twin Tutors (Legendary Creature - Human Advisor)
  73. Netherborn Phalanx (Creature - Horror)
  74. Infernal Tutor (Sorcery)
  75. The Masters of Evil (Legendary Creature - Human Villain)
  76. Disciples of Gix (Creature - Phyrexian Human)
  77. Iname, Death Aspect (Legendary Creature - Spirit)
  78. Cateran Summons (Sorcery)
  79. Night Dealings (Enchantment)
  80. Liliana's Scorn (Sorcery)
  81. Bogbrew Witch (Creature - Human Wizard)
  82. Dark Supplicant (Creature - Human Cleric)
  83. Blightspeaker (Creature - Human Rebel Cleric)
  84. Vraska's Scorn (Sorcery)
  85. Rathi Assassin (Creature - Phyrexian Zombie Mercenary Assassin)
  86. Sorin's Guide (Creature - Vampire)
  87. Cateran Enforcer (Creature - Horror Mercenary)
  88. Rathi Intimidator (Creature - Phyrexian Horror Mercenary)
  89. Cateran Kidnappers (Creature - Human Mercenary)
  90. Cateran Slaver (Creature - Horror Mercenary)
  91. Rathi Fiend (Creature - Phyrexian Horror Mercenary)
  92. Cateran Brute (Creature - Horror Mercenary)
  93. Demon's Herald (Creature - Human Wizard)
  94. Cateran Overlord (Creature - Horror Mercenary)
  95. Urborg Panther (Creature - Nightstalker Cat)
  96. Cateran Persuader (Creature - Human Mercenary)
  97. Bog Glider (Creature - Human Mercenary)
  98. Grim Reminder (Instant)
  99. Whisper Squad (Creature - Human Soldier)
  100. Smuggler Captain (Creature - Human Pirate)

How this list is built

The tutors list filtered to cards whose Commander colour identity is black alone: cards that search your library for a card that is not only a basic land, plus transmute. A gold or hybrid tutor that also needs another colour is on neither one-colour list. One entry per card, most-played first.

Built from the card data dated 2026-11-18.

Frequently asked questions

What counts as a black tutor?

A card whose Commander colour identity is black alone and that searches your library for a card (rule 701.23a). Colour identity counts the mana symbols in its mana cost and rules text (rule 903.4), and a deck can include a card only if every colour of its identity is in its commander's (rule 903.5c).

Which black tutors find any card?

Demonic Tutor and Diabolic Intent put any card into your hand, while Vampiric Tutor and Imperial Seal put it on top of your library, a draw later. A search for simply a card must find one if your library has any cards (rule 701.23d).

Which black tutors are Game Changers?

Demonic Tutor, Vampiric Tutor and Imperial Seal, on the Game Changers list dated February 9, 2026. Brackets 1 and 2 allow none of the list, and Bracket 3 up to three different ones.

Sources

  • Comprehensive Rules, effective November 6, 2026: rules 701.23a and 701.23d (searching a library) and rules 903.4 and 903.5c (colour identity).
  • Mana Grove card database, MTGJSON build of November 18, 2026: the rules text, type line and Commander legality of every card on this list, and the deck-inclusion popularity rank behind its order.

How our guides are made.

Guides

Explore Mana Grove