Black removal

837 Commander-legal cards are black removal. The most-played are Feed the Swarm, Deadly Rollick and Fell the Profane // Fell Mire (card data dated November 18, 2026).

Black removal destroys, exiles, damages or shrinks a target permanent, and each card fits any deck with black. The 837 cards, most-played first.

Build a deck around these cards: describe it to Grover, the AI deck assistant, and it drafts a full Commander list with the reasoning behind every pick.

Best black removal in Commander

Ranked most-played first, the best black removal in Commander are Feed the Swarm, Deadly Rollick, Fell the Profane // Fell Mire, Orcish Bowmasters and Infernal Grasp. Every card on this list is legal in Commander as of the card data dated November 18, 2026.

What these cards do

Black removal is the cards of black alone that remove a target permanent or make an opponent sacrifice one, so every card here fits a Commander deck with black in its colours. Black kills creatures and makes opponents sacrifice them: Infernal Grasp and Go for the Throat destroy at instant speed, Feed the Swarm also takes an enchantment, and Grave Pact makes each other player sacrifice a creature whenever one of yours dies.

This is targeted removal, one permanent or a few at a time, read from each card's rules text; sweepers that hit all or each are on the black board wipes list. A gold or hybrid card that also needs another colour is on neither one-colour list, because Commander colour identity counts every colour in its cost and rules text.

Rules note: destroy doesn't work on an indestructible permanent, while exile, a tuck, -X/-X and an edict still do; and a target with hexproof can't be chosen, so an edict, which never targets the creature, gets around it.

The list

837 cards in all. The 100 most-played are listed here, each linked to its page with printings, prices and format legality.

  1. Feed the Swarm (Sorcery)
  2. Deadly Rollick (Instant)
  3. Fell the Profane // Fell Mire (Instant)
  4. Orcish Bowmasters (Creature - Orc Archer)
  5. Infernal Grasp (Instant)
  6. Withering Torment (Instant)
  7. Go for the Throat (Instant)
  8. Accursed Marauder (Creature - Zombie Warrior)
  9. Grave Pact (Enchantment)
  10. Plaguecrafter (Creature - Human Shaman)
  11. Snuff Out (Instant)
  12. Sheoldred, Whispering One (Legendary Creature - Phyrexian Praetor)
  13. Liliana, Dreadhorde General (Legendary Planeswalker - Liliana)
  14. Fleshbag Marauder (Creature - Zombie Warrior)
  15. Bitter Triumph (Instant)
  16. Murder (Instant)
  17. Yawgmoth, Thran Physician (Legendary Creature - Human Cleric)
  18. Tragic Slip (Instant)
  19. Grim Hireling (Creature - Tiefling Rogue)
  20. Dismember (Instant)
  21. Noxious Gearhulk (Artifact Creature - Construct)
  22. Archon of Cruelty (Creature - Archon)
  23. Defile (Instant)
  24. Dictate of Erebos (Enchantment)
  25. Ravenous Chupacabra (Creature - Beast Horror)
  26. Vilis, Broker of Blood (Legendary Creature - Demon)
  27. Soul Shatter (Instant)
  28. Sheoldred's Edict (Instant)
  29. Flare of Malice (Instant)
  30. Butcher of Malakir (Creature - Vampire Warrior)
  31. Lethal Scheme (Instant)
  32. Rankle, Master of Pranks (Legendary Creature - Faerie Rogue)
  33. Baleful Mastery (Instant)
  34. Shriekmaw (Creature - Elemental)
  35. Murderous Rider // Swift End (Creature - Zombie Knight)
  36. The Eldest Reborn (Enchantment - Saga)
  37. Virtue of Persistence // Locthwain Scorn (Enchantment)
  38. Hero's Downfall (Instant)
  39. Sheoldred // The True Scriptures (Legendary Creature - Phyrexian Praetor)
  40. Hagra Mauling // Hagra Broodpit (Instant)
  41. Drown in Ichor (Sorcery)
  42. Doom Blade (Instant)
  43. Merciless Executioner (Creature - Orc Warrior)
  44. Overkill (Instant)
  45. Demon's Disciple (Creature - Human Cleric)
  46. Royal Assassin (Creature - Human Assassin)
  47. Vraska's Fall (Instant)
  48. Professor Onyx (Legendary Planeswalker - Liliana)
  49. Summon: Primal Odin (Enchantment Creature - Saga Knight)
  50. Consuming Corruption (Instant)
  51. Dread Presence (Creature - Nightmare)
  52. Witch of the Moors (Creature - Human Warlock)
  53. Will of the Abzan (Sorcery)
  54. Persistent Constrictor (Creature - Zombie Snake)
  55. Bone Shards (Sorcery)
  56. Fell (Sorcery)
  57. Witch-king of Angmar (Legendary Creature - Wraith Noble)
  58. Nowhere to Run (Enchantment)
  59. Liliana of the Veil (Legendary Planeswalker - Liliana)
  60. Fatal Push (Instant)
  61. Meathook Massacre II (Legendary Enchantment)
  62. Blowfly Infestation (Enchantment)
  63. Cornered by Black Mages (Sorcery)
  64. Eaten Alive (Sorcery)
  65. Archenemy's Charm (Instant)
  66. Chittering Witch (Creature - Human Warlock)
  67. Shambling Ghast (Creature - Zombie)
  68. Curtains' Call (Instant)
  69. Overseer of the Damned (Creature - Demon)
  70. Patron of the Vein (Creature - Vampire Shaman)
  71. Come Back Wrong (Sorcery)
  72. Astarion's Thirst (Instant)
  73. Whisper of the Dross (Instant)
  74. Vona's Hunger (Instant)
  75. Claim the Precious (Sorcery)
  76. Ob Nixilis, Unshackled (Legendary Creature - Demon)
  77. Sorin, Imperious Bloodlord (Legendary Planeswalker - Sorin)
  78. Big Game Hunter (Creature - Human Rebel Assassin)
  79. Innocent Blood (Sorcery)
  80. Ob Nixilis, the Hate-Twisted (Legendary Planeswalker - Nixilis)
  81. Sorin Markov (Legendary Planeswalker - Sorin)
  82. Erebos, Bleak-Hearted (Legendary Enchantment Creature - God)
  83. Shoot the Sheriff (Instant)
  84. Throat Slitter (Creature - Rat Ninja)
  85. Ob Nixilis Reignited (Legendary Planeswalker - Nixilis)
  86. Shadowgrange Archfiend (Creature - Demon)
  87. Demonic Junker (Artifact - Vehicle)
  88. Price of Fame (Instant)
  89. Liliana's Triumph (Instant)
  90. Season of Loss (Sorcery)
  91. Ifnir Deadlands (Land - Desert)
  92. Grim Affliction (Instant)
  93. Zodiark, Umbral God (Legendary Creature - God)
  94. Tithing Blade // Consuming Sepulcher (Artifact)
  95. Heartless Act (Instant)
  96. Black Sun's Twilight (Instant)
  97. Cut Down (Instant)
  98. Attrition (Enchantment)
  99. Suspended Sentence (Instant)
  100. Profane Command (Sorcery)

How this list is built

Commander-legal cards whose Commander colour identity is black alone and whose rules text removes one or more target permanents: destroy, exile, damage, -X/-X or -1/-1 counters, a fight, a tuck into its owner's library, or an edict that makes another player sacrifice. Sweepers of all or each (the board wipes lists), land destruction, bounce to hand and flickers are not listed. One entry per card, most-played first.

Built from the card data dated 2026-11-18.

Frequently asked questions

Why is a black card with removal missing from this list?

Usually because its colour identity is not black alone: Commander colour identity counts every coloured mana symbol in its cost and rules text (rule 903.4), and a deck may include it only if its commander has every one of those colours (rule 903.5c). Sweepers of all or each are on the black board wipes list.

What can black not remove?

Artifacts are its weak spot, and enchantments nearly so, though Feed the Swarm destroys an enchantment an opponent controls. Black destroys creatures (rule 701.8a) and makes opponents sacrifice them (rule 701.21a).

Does exile get around indestructible?

Yes. Indestructible stops only destroy, including destruction by lethal damage (rule 702.12b); exile (rule 701.13a), toughness 0 or less from -X/-X (rule 704.5f) and sacrifice (rule 701.21a) still remove the permanent.

Sources

  • Comprehensive Rules, effective November 6, 2026: rules 701.8a and 701.13a (destroy and exile), rule 701.21a (sacrifice), rules 702.12b and 704.5f (indestructible and toughness 0) and rules 903.4 and 903.5c (colour identity).
  • Mana Grove card database, MTGJSON build of November 18, 2026: the rules text, type line and Commander legality of every card on this list, and the deck-inclusion popularity rank behind its order.

How our guides are made.

Guides

Explore Mana Grove